What is the difference between retributive justice and. A paper presented at the first world congress on restorative juvenile justice, lima, peru, november 5, 2009. In the extract below, just one part of the much longer article, daly addresses what she identifies as the first myth, and argues that advocates of restorative justice have painted a dichotomous, oppositional picture of restorative versus retributive justice. Pdf retributive and restorative justice michael platow. Restoration 1, 1 2004 our present criminal justice philosophy is based on the concept of retribution, that is something given or demanded. It is a compilation of principles and practices that come together to form an approach that involves all partiesthe offender, victim, and community. An opportunity for cooperation or an occasion for conflict in the search for justice donald h. Implementing restorative justice under the retributive. A philosophical theory of punishment, christopher bennett defends a theory of state punishment that seeks to reconcile restorative justice with retributive justice by drawing upon the symbolism of two ordinary practices. As such, restorative justice practices embrace retributive justice assumptions of individual culpability and they also include a wider notion of community. Every generation has a set of obligations that they owe to the other generations.
Restorative justice programmes should provide a basis by which success may be measured. Retributive and restorative justice present two different responses to wrongdoing. Wholeschool restorative approach resource guide december 8, 2017 page 4 of 47 restorative practices provide meaningful opportunities for social engagement that foster empathy and mutual responsibility for the wellbeing of individuals and the community. Practicing justice the zwelethemba model of conflict. Retributive justice essentially refers to the repair of justice through unilateral imposition of. Defining restorative justice can be elusive because it is a philosophical framework or a way of thinking about crime and conflict, rather than a distinct model or system of law.
This is what has inspired me to look deeper into the issue of rj and the south african truth and reconciliation process in this article. Difference between restorative justice and retributive justice. Pdf retributive justice, restorative justice howard. The current generation has an obligation to preserve the living ecosystem and conserve resources like the previous generations.
Retributive and restorative justice article pdf available in law and human behavior 325. Retributive justice is a theory of justice that considers punishment, if proportionate, is a morally acceptable response to crime, by providing satisfaction and psychological benefits to the victim, the offender and society. Restorative practices schott foundation for public education. Restorative justice restorative justice continues to slowly emerge as an alternative to the more familiar forms of retributive justice in the united states. Essentially, both perspectives concentrate on rules and laws with. There is, however, a firm basis for finding a complementarity in the operation of these two processes, which ultimately have the same goal of justice. Crime is an act against individuals and the community. Justice has been done when the wrongdoer has been sufficiently punished. The international criminal court and restorative justice.
Society 2002, kathleen daly draws on her experience of restorative justice conferencing and an. Knowing this, the church is obliged to practice restorative. Revisiting the relationship between retributive and restorative. The term justice is mostly confused with or used interchangeably, by many people, with the term fairness. A system of criminal justice which focuses on the rehabilitation of offenders through reconciliation with victims and the community at large. Psychological aspects of retributive justice sciencedirect.
The authors the little book of hconferencing program in. Retribution is different from revenge because retributive justice is directed only at wrongs. Pdf retributive and restorative justice researchgate. In 1977 my colleagues and i were using restorative practices in our work with delinquent. In general, the severity of the punishment is proportionate to the seriousness of the crime. Restorative justice programmes should have published codes of practice and standards. Retributive and restorative justice australian psychological society.
Restorative versus retributive justice centre for crime and justice. I will begin by exemplifying the idea that whereas the postapartheid truth and reconciliation commission trc did not offer retributive justice, it did promote another. In 1998 the international criminal court the icc was established with a mandate that expressly included victim participation. Retributive justice believes in pain and punishment balancing the scales, while restorative justice focuses on acknowledging and addressing harms, needs, obligations, and getting at causes. In con trast to retributive justice, restorative justice operates through the offender completing reparative sanctions. The examples of restorative justice and retributive justice. Restorative justice programmes should be monitored through internal processes and evaluated through independent research to promote continuous improvement. This article identifies the important features of both restorative and. Restorative justice also serves as an alternative to retributive justice which views crime primarily as acts that violate criminal laws established by governments and rehabilitative justice which takes a therapeutic approach that addresses an offenders need for treatment. Retributive justice, response to criminal behaviour that focuses on the punishment of lawbreakers and the compensation of victims. International institute for restorative practices, graduate school, bethlehem, pennsylvania, usa. Pdf from retributive justice to restorative justice researchgate. The most basic principles of restorative justice are.
In new zealand, restorative justice has served to guide and help shape the family group conference approach which is now the basis of that countrys entire juvenile justice system. Ethical considerations are vital at the intersection of economic and environmental discourse. Justice is the quality of being righteousness, fair. However there can be a pronounced naivety or romanticism about community within much restorative justice literature. Proactive practices intentionally build trust and understanding within the community to ensure.
Restorative justice and retributive justice seattle university. Restorative justice is not a program that can be bottled. Offender accountability defined as taking punishment. It is no secret that the criminal justice system, societys means for responding to crime, is far from perfect. A theoretical justification for the use of restorative justice practices zvi d. This momentous achievement recognised victims rights.
Retributive justice essentially refers to the repair of justice through unilateral imposition of punishment, whereas restorative justice means the repair of justice through reaffirming a shared. Usually, the history of restorative justice is presented as a single obligatory paragraph at the beginning of a book or article, and appears as a mere preface to the. Pdf the emergence of restorative justice as an alternative model to western, courtbased criminal justice may have important implications for the. Retributive justice is a theory of punishment that when an offender breaks the law, justice requires that she suffers in return. Principles of restorative justice and restoration at the centre of the restorative justice concept lies the idea that crimes or wrongdoings are violations of people and relationships and that acceptance of responsibility is required before the process of restoration can begin. The emergence of restorative justice as an alternative model to western, courtbased criminal justice may have important implications for the psychology of justice. Using the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty and the international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr as case studies, it begins by examining whether international war crimes tribunals, as dispensers of retributive justice, can contribute to reconciliation. A number of accompanying procedural safeguards informed by human rights imperatives were also expressed. A system of criminal justice based on the punishment of offende. Retribution appears alongside restorative principles in law codes from the. Org restitution is the payment by an offender of a sum of money to compensate the victim for the financial losses caused by the crime. Restorative justice retributive justice restorative justice problem defined narrowly, abstractly, a legal. Crime is an act against another person and the community.
The little book of restorative justice by howard zehr. Prevention of future crimes or rehabilitation of the offender are other purposes of punishment. It is proposed that two different notions of justice affect responses to rulebreaking. Retributive and distributive justice evergreen scene x.
Crime is an act against the state, a violation of a law, an abstract idea. Incorporating restorative and community justice into american sentencing and corrections by leena kurki p rograms based on restorative and community justice principles have proliferated in the united states over the past decade simultaneously with toughoncrime initiatives like threestrikes, truthinsentencing, and mandatory minimum laws. Zehr imagines a world where our justice system is as restorative as possible. It also requires that the response to a crime is proportional to the offence. A report on the relationship between restorative justice. Retributive justice connotes that the offender committed a crime against the state and has thereby violated the law and the moral code of the state. The justice process involves all voices in dialogue to negotiate reparation to victim and community. My three decades of using restorative practices with. Retributive justice is sometimes regarded as part of distributive justice, because distributive justice is in turn concerned with what people deserve for their actions. This article explores the relationship between retributive justice, restorative justice, and reconciliation. To some extent, of course, this is a question of nomenclature, but the great bulk of distributive justice research has concerned itself with what one positively deserves, in. European forum of restorative justice and restorative justice consortium, uk and eu it is a concise, engaging, innovative and informative book for. The ultimate goal of the theory of retributive justice is not. Exploring the history of the restorative justice movement.
As a model for criminal justice, the cycle of blame and apology that we typically undergo when we do wrong to each other. Transitional justice an analysis of restorative and retributive. Divine justice as restorative justice 11 divine justice as restorative justice by chris marshall while it contains retributive components, gods justice is fundamentally a restoring and renewing justice. Restorative justice retributive restorative crime is an act against the state and its laws. In 2003, the united nations department of economic and social affairs desa recognized the importance of restorative justice as another way to address crime and conflict beyond traditional criminal justice. Promoting restorative justice for children the special representative of the secretarygeneral on violence against children is an independent global advocate in favour of the prevention and elimination. It goes beyond how we think about crime and conflict.
341 93 1493 538 562 286 81 30 234 1199 1094 1145 370 1516 368 1318 821 1248 1169 473 1190 301 118 705 856 221 1255 1053 1380 696 1276 715 1473 322